Judge orders state to immediately allow Missourians to enroll in expanded Medicaid
The state had argued it needed two months to begin accepting applications for the program approved by voters last year
Cole County Judge Jon Beetem (screenshot courtesy of KRCG-TV)
The Missouri Department of Social Services must allow newly eligible residents that qualify for benefits under voter-approved Medicaid expansion to enroll and cannot impose greater restrictions on them, a Cole County judge ruled Tuesday.
Cole County Circuit Court Judge Jon Beetem sided with the plaintiffs who urged him to allow Medicaid expansion to take effect as soon as possible, rather than allow the state to make its case for why it needs two more months to begin accepting newly-eligible residents.
Attorney Chuck Hatfield, who represented plaintiffs challenging the state, said it’s time to stop talking about implementing Medicaid expansion and start doing it.
“It’s great that the courts have — today on the 200th anniversary of Missouri — enforced that will, and said, ‘Yeah, you actually have to do what the people voted for,'” Hatfield said. “That’s how this is supposed to work and it’s a good day.”
Nina Canaleo, a 38-year-old Kansas City resident who receives no health insurance through her part-time job cleaning a grocery store at night, said it was about time.
“This time they finally have to abide by something that we all voted on and then it passed,” Canaleo said. “Stop dragging their feet.”
For Canaleo, the roughly $14,000 she makes a year isn’t enough to sufficiently treat her multiple sclerosis, a chronic nerve disease that leaves her with numb and swollen feet. She was only able to purchase health insurance this year after a fundraiser helped her cover the costs. Tuesday’s decision helps relieve the stress of knowing Medicaid will be an option when that runs out.
“Every day my illness just gets worse. And just to subside that a little bit is great,” Canaleo said, later adding: “If I can get all the medical, I can get to where I can go to work. That’d be great. I’m not ready to stop working.”
A spokesman for Missouri Attorney General Eric Schmitt declined to comment on Tuesday’s ruling. The governor’s office and DSS did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
“I haven’t seen the entire ruling, but let me say this: I’m going to follow the law. I’ve always done that and always will continue to do that,” Gov. Mike Parson said Tuesday, according to the St. Louis Post-Dispatch.
The Missouri attorney general’s office argued last week that while implementation was underway, that it would be difficult to immediately begin carrying out Medicaid expansion and said computer systems and personnel still needed to be put in place. John Sauer, the solicitor general of Missouri, requested Beetem grant another hearing for witnesses from MO HealthNet and the Family Support Division within DSS to testify to that point.
However, attorneys who represent three women who would have qualified for coverage under the expanded Medicaid program that voters approved in August 2020, said doing so would continue to allow the state to violate the law.
“‘Don’t deny,’ that’s what we’re asking you to tell them,” Hatfield told Beetem last week. “Don’t deny.”
A spokeswoman for DSS did not immediately respond to a request for comment last week on whether the department has paused processing or denied new applications it has received since July 1 from newly eligible residents who qualify under Medicaid expansion.
Last month, the Missouri Supreme Court overturned Beetem’s earlier ruling, unanimously ordering Missouri to expand Medicaid to the approximately 275,000 residents who became eligible when it would have gone into effect July 1.
By allocating funds for the Medicaid program, the state must allow all eligible to access those benefits — and cannot differentiate between eligible populations, like those who previously qualified versus those newly eligible.
Under the constitutional amendment passed last year, 19 to 64-year-old adults whose household incomes are 138 percent of the federal poverty guideline or less would qualify for benefits under Missouri’s Medicaid program.
That ends up being $17,774 a year for a single person, or $36,570 for a family of four.
Despite passing with 53.3 percent of the vote, lawmakers refused to appropriate the $1.9 billion in state and federal funds needed to finance Medicaid expansion. In May, the state ultimately withdrew a plan it had submitted to federal regulators as a result.
Part of plaintiffs’ request was that Beetem order the state to submit a new state plan amendment — which attorneys for the state indicated DSS plans to do and have apply retroactively to July 1, the date Medicaid expansion would have gone into effect.
Parson said his administration is making plans to move forward, in addition to preparing to resubmit a state plan amendment to the federal government — “but we really cannot until we find out: do we have the ability to do that,” Parson told St. Louis Public Radio’s “Politically Speaking” last week.
“What I really don’t want is some judge deciding for us how we’re going to implement this from an area he has no experience in,” Parson said. “And the other thing, if we do have to implement — if we do — I don’t want to be in a position where we lose the 90 percent match from the federal government. And that’s a reality.”
Under the Affordable Care Act, states pay 10 percent of the costs of newly eligible Medicaid participants, with the federal government matching the remaining 90 percent.
Parson said he will not call a special session to allocate additional funding unless there’s a plan in place. He also said he does not want a repeat of cuts to Missouri’s Medicaid rolls that former Republican Gov. Matt Blunt pushed in 2005, which ended up booting tens of thousands of people off Medicaid who had already signed up.
But Parson said if there is no additional funding appropriated to fund Medicaid expansion, it could be a reality.
“And in this particular instance it’s even worse, because now you’re talking about able-bodied adults,” Parson told St. Louis Public Radio. “And are you going to take somebody that’s disabled off the system? Are you going to take somebody else that has health issues off of that for an able-bodied adult? I don’t think anybody wants that.”
Hatfield said he hopes there’s no need for any additional legal action and that implementation will go smoothly — knowing it will take some time to process new applications.
Shortly after Tuesday’s order was released, Missouri Jobs With Justice, an advocacy organization that was part of the coalition that campaigned for expansion’s passage, urged residents with questions on whether they qualify for coverage to call a hotline to get answers.
Senate Minority Leader John Rizzo, D-Independence, celebrated Beetem’s ruling as the culmination of a long push to expand health care coverage in Missouri.
“The latest Republican attempt to block and delay Medicaid expansion has failed,” he tweeted shortly after the ruling was issued. “The state must begin enrolling eligible ppl and they must begin now. Let’s be clear: Healthcare for working families is a good thing. Glad to see Eric Schmitt’s losing streak continue.”
This story has been updated since it was first published.
Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.